Understanding Mental Health: Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder vs. OCD
Obsessive-compulsive disorder is a common mental health disorder. A specific type of anxiety disorder, people living with this condition have obsessions (intrusive or distressing thoughts) and compulsions (the urge for repetitive behaviors like hand-washing or counting to reduce anxiety). What might not be as commonly understood is obsessive-compulsive personality disorder, a personality disorder with a similar name but distinct differences when compared to obsessive-compulsive disorder. So, what is the difference between obsessive-compulsive personality disorder vs. OCD? It largely comes down to how the person views these obsessive or compulsive thoughts. Before we explain how WhiteSands Treatment’s team of experts can help people overcome addiction while also learning how to conquer and manage co-occurring disorders like OCD, let’s explain the difference between these two overlapping but distinct mental health conditions.
OCD typically begins in childhood but can occur later in life, stemming from unique factors or events, according to WebMD. It can be a short-term issue, but it is treatable. Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder, meanwhile, is something that the person is more or less born with. It’s a lifelong condition because it is a personality disorder, disrupting their thoughts and behaviors and potentially leading to major distress. The major difference between the two is how people view the thoughts they have because of the disorders. When someone has OCD, they are aware that their excessive and intrusive thoughts are unwanted, and they can feel anxious about it. Someone with OCPD, meanwhile, typically won’t be self-aware about this issue, and they simply believe their thoughts are correct. When they can’t control a situation, they’re prone to become angry or filled with rage instead of anxious. Another difference between obsessive-compulsive personality disorder vs. OCD is that people with OCD tend to be insecure about their feelings, especially their obsessions and compulsions. Someone with OCPD, instead, will tend to hide their insecurities — from others and even from themself.
What Are the Four Levels of OCD?
Now that you better understand the difference between obsessive-compulsive personality disorder vs. OCD, let’s take a deeper look at obsessive-compulsive disorder. OCD is an anxiety disorder with four main types:
- Cleaning: Someone with this form of OCD will be intensely afraid of contamination and will compulsively complete cleaning rituals. Their fear might revolve around germs, dirt, or bodily fluids, and they tend to repeatedly wash their hands or take long, multiple showers to try to feel clean.
- Order: Because they feel like everything needs to be perfectly arranged, ordered, and balanced, someone with this form of OCD might compulsively line up objects or count items.
- Harm: This form of OCD is marked by an obsessive fear that they’ll somehow injure or harm others or themselves.
- Hoarding: This severe type of OCD means people have a very difficult time getting rid of things, even trash, broken items, or things that almost anyone else around them would consider unnecessary or not worth keeping.
What Is the Hardest Type of OCD to Treat?
Obsessive-compulsive disorder can be a short-term problem, and the good news is that treatment is available, typically in the form of a combination of medications and intensive therapy. However, some types of OCD tend to be harder to treat than others. Hoarding, especially, often won’t respond well to typical medications and therapy options, such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT). A unique form of OCD known as purely obsessional OCD is also difficult to treat because medications and exposure and response prevention tend not to be effective. Someone with purely obsessional OCD suffers from intrusive thoughts that could be about harming others, relationships, religious or moral issues, or sexuality and gender. However, they don’t have physical compulsions like repeated hand-washing or counting.
What Are 3 Symptoms of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder?
Now that you better understand the types of OCD and the core differences between obsessive-compulsive personality disorder vs. OCD let’s further explain some more aspects of this unique personality disorder. Unlike the myth of an “addictive” personality type, OCPD is very much a real personality disorder.
According to MedlinePlus, Someone with OCPD will be preoccupied with these three core things:
- Rules.
- Orderliness.
- Control.
Genetic predisposition may be at play in OCPD, like other personality disorders, and it tends to run in families. Childhood and environmental factors might also play a role. Often, someone with OCPD will begin to suffer from the personality disorder in their teens or early 20s. While OCPD sufferers can be high achievers, their rigidity and demand for perfectionism and control at all times can make them frustrated or angry, and it can interfere with their ability to make friendships or maintain relationships with family members or co-workers.
Some symptoms of OCPD include:
- Being overly devoted to work.
- Inflexibility and lacking generosity.
- Not being able to delegate responsibilities because they think others can’t do things correctly.
- Not showing affection.
- Being overly preoccupied with details or needing to rigidly adhere to rules or regulations.
What Kind of Trauma Causes OCPD?
MedlinePlus says OCPD tends to run in families, and a genetic predisposition is possible. Still, childhood experiences and environmental factors are also likely to play a role in the causes of this disease. A 2023 article in the journal Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy says multiple pieces of research and studies have pointed to trauma as a possible risk factor for developing obsessive-compulsive personality disorder.
In particular, some research in the past has suggested a particularly strong association between OCPD and trauma high in interpersonal betrayal. This specific type of trauma happens when someone’s happiness or well-being is threatened or affected by someone or something important in their life, such as a child who is betrayed by a parent or guardian when they become the victim of abuse or when social support systems and institutions betray the trust of a person. To examine this possible link, the authors of the 2023 report examined the OCPD pathology in 300 participants. They found that trauma, in general, was associated with OCPD among the sample group. Still, interpersonal trauma high in betrayal had a stronger link between trauma and this personality disorder for men.
WhiteSands Treatment Can Treat Addiction and OCD
While there is some overlap between obsessive-compulsive personality disorder vs. OCD, how these two mental health conditions are treated can differ considerably. At WhiteSands Treatment’s network of drug and alcohol rehabs across Florida, our experts offer dual diagnosis treatment to heal the root causes of addiction while also addressing some common mental health disorders, including depression, PTSD, and anxiety disorders like OCD. We know that breaking the chains of addiction also requires examining and treating the root causes of substance abuse, including mental health difficulties like OCD that can fuel addiction. That’s why we take a comprehensive approach and work with patients to address both simultaneously so they can get on the road to recovery and maintain long-lasting sobriety after treatment is done. Learn more about what we can do for you or a loved one today by calling us at 877-855-3470.
External Sources
- WebMD — OCD vs. OCPD
- MedlinePlus — Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder
- National Library of Medicine — Influence of Betrayal Trauma on Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Pathology
If you or a loved one needs help with abuse and/or treatment, please call the WhiteSands Treatment at (877) 855-3470. Our addiction specialists can assess your recovery needs and help you get the addiction treatment that provides the best chance for your long-term recovery.
About the Author
Jackie has been involved in the substance abuse and addiction treatment sector for over five years and this is something that she is truly eager about. She has a passion for writing and continuously works to create informative pieces that not only educate and inform the public about the disease of addiction but also provide solutions for those who struggle with drug and alcohol abuse.
